Posted on

Privacy Tools: Ghostery vs. Adblock Plus

they__re_watching_you__by_dharmainitiative2010-d34asq6.png

How many times have you heard this line?  “They’re watching you…” (A lot, I would imagine.)

Unfortunately, I’ve begun to realize that it’s true (at least with regard to the web).  Even when using the Tor network, which was created with privacy in mind, you’re still under surveillance, which is why some people have stopped using it altogether. (Although that hasn’t stopped me, the intrepid writer.)

Nonetheless, when you’re on the clearnet, there are some tools and plugins that can enhance your privacy (if not ensure it 100% of the time).

In a previous post, If We Built This Large Wooden Privacy Badger…, I discussed the plugin Privacy Badger, created by the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF).  For the most part, I’ve had a very positive experience with said Badger – he’s not a friend of trackers, trust me:

4935347

So, I thought it reasonable to compare some of the other popular privacy tools with Privacy Badger, to see which worked the best.

Do You Believe in Ghostery?

ghostery-logo-dark2

*ba-domp ching!*  For those who haven’t heard of Ghostery, it’s a web privacy-themed company; they’re the developers of the Ghostery browser extension.  The extension monitors the various web servers that are being called upon from any given webpage, and makes them correspond with a list of data collection tools (a.k.a. trackers).

And yes, I realize it’s already been reviewed on Lifehacker and other sites, but I still wanted to take a stab at it, and not just take everyone else’s word for it.

With Ghostery enabled, each time you visit a webpage, it searches for all the trackers connected to that site, and compiles them into a neat list, which it will display each time you access a new site:

ghostery blocklist

If you then look at the icon displayed on your menu bar, a little number should be showing next to it, indicating how many trackers have been found on that specific site.  Click that icon, and a dropdown menu (called the “Findings Panel”) will list the specific names of the trackers.  From that menu, you can choose to block or allow any specific tracker:

ghostery_trackers

Granted, as with Privacy Badger and some of the other privacy apps, if you disable all the trackers on certain sites, the sites won’t work properly.  This, of course, is why you have the option of enabling or disabling each tracker individually.

If you only want to temporarily pause blocking so that you can use all of a site’s functions, then that’s what the “Pause Blocking” button is for.  On the other hand, if you trust a site completely, you can click “Whitelist Site.”

Like this blog, right?  You trust me, don’t you??

frabz-Trust-me-Im-the-Doctor-8b7624

All in all, I’ve found Ghostery to be quite useful, but I choose to opt out of their GhostrankTM feature, which “collects anonymous data about the trackers you’ve encountered and the sites on which they were placed.” In theory, this feature is used to help businesses market themselves more transparently (and in a less intrusive way), but it’s also a way for Ghostery to make money – hey, did you think they were doing this for free?

Finally, under its options, Ghostery will show you a list of trackers that it’s blocked, in different categories (e.g. Advertising, Analytics, etc.).  You can choose to enable or disable any of these functions in order to optimize your web experience.

ghostery_whitelist

Cockblock Plus…I mean…Adblock Plus

cbp

Excuse me, little Freudian slip there!! This is what I meant:

Adblock-plus-logo

Adblock Plus is, in a sense, very similar to Ghostery. Sometimes, however, they block different trackers (or different types of trackers).

Actually, one immediate difference that I noticed between ABP and Ghostery was that Ghostery tells you which specific domains it’s blocking, whereas ABP doesn’t.  It merely tells you how many ads its blocked on that page, as well as how many in total.

As a matter of fact, this initially appears to be a disadvantage, because it’s kind of an “all-or-nothing” approach.  However, ABP has a different method for blocking specific elements on a page.

If you right-click on certain page elements, a menu like this should appear (this one’s for Chrome) :

dropdown menu

Click the option that says “Block element.”  Another window should appear, listing the specific page element – you can then add that to your “blacklist” of blocked elements.

blockelement

All in all, Adblock Plus works similarly to Ghostery, but after playing around with it a little, it seems slightly more geared toward the techies among us (me included)!  So really, which one you use (if any) is just a matter of personal preference.

That being said, these are far from the only privacy tools available – perhaps I shall save the rest for a future post.

In the meantime, I’m going to go back to hiding in my paranoia shelter.

paranoid-parrot-meme-8

 

Advertisements

About secretsofthedark

Have you heard of the dark web? Simply put, it's the "hidden internet" built on networks like Tor. "Secrets of the Dark" chronicles my dark web experiences, but is also aimed at demythologizing it and teaching about it. Want to reproduce one of the "horror stories"? Contact me at ciphas@protonmail.com.

5 responses to “Privacy Tools: Ghostery vs. Adblock Plus

  1. Pingback: Privacy Tools Part 2: uBlock Origin, RedMorph Browser Controller | Secrets of the Dark

  2. I have been using ghostery for a while and has been working great until March 17, 2017. When watching shows online commercials are now popping up. I have contacted ghostery twice with no response. Any suggestions?

  3. Red ⋅

    Would you be willing to update your blog post with a quick review of running both blockers together, at the same time, and the effectiveness or needless redundancy of doing so?

    Thanks for the review.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s